In an emotionally charged episode that blended heartfelt family tributes with Disney enchantment, American Idol has officially narrowed its Season 22 competition down to the Top 5 contestants. The May 11 double-feature episode, which aired on ABC, offered both spectacle and sentiment as two more hopefuls were eliminated following performances themed around Disney favorites and Mother’s Day dedications.
Disney Magic Meets Heartfelt Homage
The evening kicked off with the return of Disney Night, a familiar yet always vibrant highlight of the season. This year, the event was expanded across two parts, with musical visionary Lin-Manuel Miranda mentoring the Top 7 in the first half. Contestants tackled beloved tracks from Disney and Pixar films, working to blend nostalgia with vocal prowess.
In a whimsical nod to Alice in Wonderland, country superstar and Idol alum Carrie Underwood made an appearance in costume, ready to usher in the emotionally heavier second half of the episode. This segment was dedicated to Mother’s Day, a theme that pushed contestants to share deeply personal performances honoring their mothers or maternal figures.
Raw Emotion from the Contestants
One of the most poignant performances came from Breanna Nix, who emotionally battled through Lauren Alaina’s “Like My Mother Does.” Her trembling voice and tearful delivery struck a chord with both the audience and judges, showcasing the raw vulnerability that the show often thrives on.
Another standout was Thunderstorm Artis, whose original composition, “Out of the Blue,” was a moving tribute to his wife, Faith. The performance was not only musically compelling but also visually emotional as well—Faith stood in the crowd holding their baby, visibly moved by the song inspired by their love story. Artis’ lyrics painted a picture of chance meetings and enduring devotion, prompting host Ryan Seacrest to joke, “I’ve never been more depressed to be single than in this moment,” after quoting the song.
Who Went Home?
Despite the beauty and resonance of the performances, the night still ended with a difficult decision. Based on America’s vote, the two contestants leaving the competition were Mattie Pruitt—the youngest singer in the running—and Baltimore’s powerhouse vocalist, Gabby Samone. Both had delivered strong performances throughout the season but fell short in capturing enough viewer support to move forward.
Their exits mark a turning point as American Idol barrels toward its grand finale, with only five contestants now vying for the coveted title.
Why It Matters
With just weeks left before the Season 22 finale, this episode was a reminder of what American Idol has evolved into—a platform not just for talent but for personal stories, emotional expression, and nationwide connection. Disney Night may have brought the magic, but the Mother’s Day segment delivered the emotional gravity that fans have come to expect from late-season episodes.
As the Top 5 prepare for the next round of challenges, the emotional weight of their personal stories and musical growth will likely continue to play a crucial role in how audiences vote. For longtime viewers, the blend of storytelling and song serves as a poignant reminder of what makes Idol more than just a singing competition.
What’s Next for ‘American Idol’?
With two major themed nights behind them, the remaining contestants will now head into high-stakes performances that could include original music, judges’ song choices, or collaborations with past winners. As momentum builds, every note—and every fan vote—counts more than ever.
Stay tuned for next week’s episode as American Idol narrows the competition even further, leading to the finale that will crown America’s next musical star.
Would you like a preview or detailed breakdown of the Top 5 contestants and their standout moments so far?
